FMCSA Upholds Revocation Over Driver's English Proficiency
FMCSA's Deputy Administrator, acting as Agency Decisionmaker, denied Arce Trucking LLC's petition to reverse the revocation of its operating authority registration. The agency revoked the Nevada carrier's authority in June 2026 after its sole driver and managing member, Alejandro Arce Posada, was cited three times between 2023 and 2026 for violating 49 CFR 391.11(b)(2), the rule requiring drivers to read and speak English well enough to respond to official inquiries and highway signs. FMCSA said the carrier knew of the violations for years but kept dispatching the driver, including twice after he was placed out of service.
Arce Trucking argued it had acted in good faith by enrolling the driver in an English course and that revocation was disproportionate for a single-driver business with no crashes. The Director countered that course enrollment does not prove current proficiency and that the carrier only promised to pull the driver from the road after the revocation order issued, not before. FMCSA agreed, finding the carrier willfully failed to show compliance and upheld the revocation. The order notes 391.11(b)(2) was reinstated as an out-of-service violation on June 25, 2025.
What's next
- Arce Trucking may petition FMCSA for rescission under 49 CFR 385.915 if it can show corrective action.
- The carrier may also appeal this final order to a U.S. Court of Appeals under 28 U.S.C. 2342(3)(A).
All sources
- Other: In the Matter of Arce Trucking LLC - Final Order on Petition for Review of Revocation of Operating Authority Registration — Regulations.gov (FMCSA), 2026-11-17

